CPCColorado Preventive CardiologyStephen Parcell, ND, ABAAHP
Back to all posts
August 25, 2021

Vegetarian Diets and Heart Disease

There is very good scientific data supporting the role of diet in the prevention of disease, especially cardiovascular disease. Many of the foods we grew up eating and are considered part of our cultural food heritage but not good for our cardiovascular health. It’s an inconvenient truth.

As anyone who knows me can attest my practice style is evidence-based. I use objective data to back up virtually everything I do with patients. I will cite individual studies to support specific topics in this article. There are many more studies on each subject that all come up with the same conclusion for every point I make.

Eating foods that are bad for us is the main reason that heart attacks are the number one cause of death in Western societies and in many other countries too. The case supporting the role of nutrition in human disease becomes stronger every year. I am going to stick to the relationship between diet and cardiovascular disease for this article.

Trendy diets can be good!

It’s trendy to refer to vegetarian diets as plant-based now instead of vegan or vegetarian. Vegan might be too politically charged but vegetarian always work for me. Vegetarian means no animal foods. If people are eating cheese and eggs and fish, they are not vegetarian.

According to the Good Food Institute which tracks industry trends there is rising popularity in plant-based diets. According to their website sales of plant-based foods that replace animal foods have increased 30 percent in the last 2 years. Eating a super healthy whole foods plant-based diet is trendy now. A whole food plant-based diet (WFPBD) does not just avoid animal products though. Advocates of this diet have raised the bar to include great emphasis on whole foods while eating only minimal processed foods. In the past the vegan diet was more about what you didn’t eat. It was possible to have nutritional deficiencies because the books written back in the 70s and 80s weren’t very good. I remember trying mostly raw vegan diet in the 90s and my hair started falling out. It was totally imbalanced. Way too high in carbs and low in protein and healthy fats.

The emphasis now is on adequate plant protein, healthy fats and avoidance of overly processed plant foods. A processed food is anything that does not look like the food in its natural state. The reason this raises the bar is because whole foods are much higher in vitamins minerals and phytonutrients than processed plant foods. Processed foods contain less nutrients, fiber, phytonutrients and typically contain more salt than is recommended. Vegetarian or vegan do not mean much without good food choices. I tell patients it is not what you don’t eat. It’s what you do eat that matters.

In the HBO documentary The Weight of the Nation, conducted in concert with Institute of Medicine of the National Academies, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and National Institutes of Health, it was noted that if you “go with the flow” in the US, you will eventually become obese.1 Old habits die hard.

The reason for this is that prevailing dietary customs coupled with marketing efforts made by the food industry far outweigh education on a healthy diet. When was the last time you saw an ad describing the importance of eating whole unprocessed foods? Many of the dietary customs we have in the United States evolved when we were much more physically active. They also developed out of necessity.

Eggs, cheese, bacon grease, lard, and preserved meats were all necessities for survival. Processing grains into flour provided important calories during the winter leading to better survival and less malnutrition. Life was hard and recipes were designed for taste, cost and practicality, but not for health. We also died sooner from a lot of other things other than heart attacks! Later in the 60s and 70s we had an explosion of marketing of highly profitable comfort, fast and junk foods. Obviously, this continues today.

Eat real food

Animal food replacement products such as plant-based meat and plant-based cheese are also still highly processed foods and not particularly good for you because they are high in salt and fat. They should not be a regular part of the diet. Plant based meats can be similar or even higher in fat and sodium compared to beef. A major however here: they do not contain cholesterol, are low in saturated fat and contain fiber. Importantly unwanted disease-causing compounds such as heterocyclic amines (HAs), advanced glycated end products (AGEs), accumulated pesticides, growth hormones and antibiotics are also avoided by eating a veggie burger.

A plant-based diet can be hard to follow correctly. I know this because I have been eating this way for two years now. One should not rely on convenience foods such as bread, pasta, excessive nut butter, meat and cheese replacement products, granola and sweets. I know because I’ve been caught in this trap. Although avoiding animal foods may reduce intake of unwanted toxins, the diet should contain mainly whole foods and adequate protein. Eat foods that look like the food in the natural state much as possible.

An example would be edamame rather than tofu, beans instead of a bean burger, brown rice instead of white rice, whole grains instead of processed flour, cereal and crackers, corn instead of corn chips, potatoes instead of potato chips etc. Coconut ice cream, vegan cookies, crackers, chips, white bread, candy, energy bars and bagels with vegan cream cheese are typical foods that are easy to eat but do not promote health. There is quite a bit of marketing on these animal product alternatives because they are tasty and easy. I just learned that Domino’s is offering a meat alternative pepperoni pizza. Other fast food chains have meat free burgers. This stuff is ultra processed and loaded with salt. Don’t get caught in this trap. It’s still okay to eat these convenience foods in moderation. Have a cauliflower crust pizza, plant-based sausage, coconut ice cream, or a plant-based burger. Just not all the time.

A vegetarian diet that includes eggs and cheese can be just as bad as a standard American diet if one puts cheese on everything and does not eat enough fruit and vegetables! Additionally, a clean whole food, organic, farm raised, diet containing meat can be better than a poor vegetarian diet! The meat would need to be unprocessed and steamed not roasted or barbecued. A Paleo style diet done correctly (which is stricter than most people realize) can work well in some people if the saturated fat is kept down and the vegetable intake is high. Whole food always trumps processed food.

But why is meat bad?

Cooking meat generates toxins. Here I will go through the 4 major unwanted toxins found in animal foods largely related to cooking methods:

Advanced glycated end products (AGEs): More than 500 foods have been tested for advanced glycated end products. AGEs occur when proteins and fats become exposed to sugar and become glycated through chemical reaction. This reaction is accelerated with heat. AGEs cause disease to both large and small arteries through the formation of bonds between molecules. In the artery this process deteriorates the integrity of the artery wall. AGEs promote aging of all tissues.2 There is even a receptor for these dangerous molecules. It’s called the receptor for advanced glycation end products (RAGE). RAGE interacts with AGEs, resulting in chronic inflammation. RAGE signaling has been implicated in multiple human illnesses, including diabetes, atherosclerosis, arthritis, Alzheimer’s disease, atherosclerosis and aging associated diseases.3 Diabetes is a disease that causes accelerated aging because of the high blood sugar reacts with proteins in the body creating AGEs and tissue damage. Drug companies are working on drugs to counteract AGEs.

Cooking methods matter. High heat especially in the presence of marinades containing sugar and sauces are the worst. High heat alone like flame broiling is also bad. If you are cooking meat cook it with the lowest heat possible, or even better, steam it. The #1 worse food on the AGEs list was fried bacon. Barbecued chicken breast with skin was the second worst. This is because of the heat and the fact that barbecue sauce contains sugar. Interested readers can see an extensive list in this article.4 In general meat, cheese and highly processed foods contain the highest age content of AGEs and grains, beans, bread, vegetables, fruits and milk have the least. Try to avoid roasted nuts as they have a pretty high content too. Eat raw nuts only. Nuts contain healthy fats, minerals, vitamins, fiber and protein!

Heterocyclic amines (HCAs): HCAs are a major class of toxic compounds produced during the broiling and frying of carnitine-containing foods such as meats. Carnitine is an amino acid. HCAs are genotoxic, which means they eventually foster mutagenicity (gene damage) and carcinogenicity (cancer), in addition to endothelial injury (damage to the artery).5

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs): Ubiquitous in the environment, at least 90% of exposure to PAHs occurs through the diet. Meat-cooking methods such as roasting, grilling, barbecuing, and smoking generate PAHs. These compounds cause oxidative stress, increase BP, and promote endothelial injury.6

When we eat plant foods with meat the vitamin C content blocks the formation of these carcinogens. Here is another reason to load up on fruits and vegetables. The extra vitamin C can help prevent some of this carcinogenic activity.

Nitrates, nitrites and nitrosamines: A study published in the prestigious peer review medical Journal The Lancet called “the global burden of disease study” provided some unnerving evidence on preserved meats. Bacon, bologna, ham and hot dogs and other processed meats are thought to be responsible for the deaths of about 800,000 people every year. That is worse than soft drinks at 300,000 per year. Preserved meats contain nitrites and nitrates as well as sodium. Nitrites are also found in plant foods but are only harmful when they turn into nitrosamines and nitrosamides. This only occurs in the presence of amines and amides, found in abundance in animal products. Some nitrosamines and nitrosamides are also found to much lesser extent in a variety of different plant foods. Nitrates are different in all talk about those later.

Nitrites are used to preserve the coloring of meats and prevent the growth of certain bacteria. Some uncured bacon products say “nitrite free” but they get around this by adding “concentrated plant nitrites” so it is not really true. Avoid cured meats please, especially bacon. The excessive heating required to cook it correctly produces the highest levels of carcinogenic molecules ever recorded.

Deli meat, though a convenient food, is also not good for you. Unfortunately, it is remarkably high in sodium and may also contain high levels of nitrites. If you are going to eat deli meat, get roasted organic meat without any preservatives like the type at whole foods.

Naturally occurring nitrates are great for blood pressure. Beets and leafy greens especially arugula are high in them. The body converts nitrates to nitric oxide (NO) a molecule that helps relax arteries, improve circulation and lower blood pressure. Athletes use shots of beet juice to improve exercise performance because of this. Nitric oxide and works as an antioxidant in addition to opening up arteries.

The top 10 sources of healthy plant sources of nitrates (not nitrites) starting with foods highest are: Arugula, rhubarb, cilantro, butter leaf lettuce, beet greens, oak leaf lettuce, Swiss chard and beets. Drinking beet juice prior to exercise can improve performance.

So, to clarify, eating animal products with added nitrites and nitrates should be avoided. Naturally occurring nitrates found in plant foods are very beneficial for cardiovascular health. Think beets not beef.

IGF-1

Meat eaters have higher blood levels of IGF-I. Adults with higher IGF-I numbers compared to those with lower numbers have a higher risk of cancer. IGF-I acts like growth hormone in the body and may promote the growth of tumors.

Endotoxins

There can be a spike in inflammation that can occur within an hour after eating a meal containing animal foods. Endotoxins are bacterial toxins that can be present in animal foods . The bacteria load in raw or cooked animal foods and fermented foods may trigger a surge of inflammation especially in the presence of saturated animal fat.

If you are curious about what to eat and want recipes there are great cookbooks and other books out there. There is a lot available online as well, especially on Instagram.

Here are some cookbooks that are a good starting point:

  1. Forks Over Knives―The Cookbook: Over 300 Recipes for Plant-Based Eating All Through the Year
  2. High-Protein Plant-Based Diet Cookbook: Vegan Bodybuilding Diet Book for Athletic Performance and Muscle Growth with Low-Carb, High-Protein Foods.
  3. The Plantpower Way: Whole Food Plant-Based Recipes and Guidance for The Whole Family: A Cookbook
  4. The How Not to Die Cookbook: 100+ Recipes to Help Prevent and Reverse Disease
  5. Plant-Strong: Discover the World’s Healthiest Diet–with 150 Engine 2 Recipes
  6. The Prevent and Reverse Heart Disease Cookbook: Over 125 Delicious, Life-Changing, Plant- Based Recipes
  7. How Not to Diet
  8. There are many more

Films and documentaries:

How exactly does a plant-based diet work to slow the progression of coronary artery disease and lower cholesterol?

  1. Cholesterol intake goes down because plants do not contain cholesterol. It should be noted that 70-80 percent of the cholesterol in your blood comes from your own liver though. Some individuals are more sensitive to dietary cholesterol than others. The reverse is also true. Some people make robust levels of cholesterol in the liver and diet has little effect. Not everyone will respond in the same way to a low cholesterol diet.

  2. The monounsaturated fats in nuts, olives and avocado protect against the negative consequences of saturated fat. Saturated fat promotes risk of diabetes because of its effect on the cell membrane. The result is decreased insulin sensitivity and high blood sugar. Current evidence is now supporting a stronger role of saturated fat and insulin resistance than sugar. Sugar feeds the fire after the cell membrane is loaded up with saturated fat.

  3. Saturated fat intake typically goes down significantly. Saturated fat of animal origin is pro-inflammatory. It also raises cholesterol production by the liver. Arachidonic and palmitic acids are fatty acids largely responsible for this. One caveat here is that palm oil and coconut oil are rich in saturated fat too. In addition, palm oil contains palmitic acid so be careful with the consumption of that fat because it boosts inflammation, diabetes and cardiovascular disease.7 It is pervasive in the food industry and is the main ingredient in no-stir nut butters, especially peanut butter. We do not want to overconsume saturated plant fats.

  4. Intake of the amino acid carnitine and the nutrient choline also decreases by avoiding animal products. This is important because these nutrients can be converted into an unpleasant substance called trimethylamine-N-oxide or TMAO. The research on TMAO and atherosclerosis is quite clear to date.8 I have yet to see carnitine or choline deficiency on blood testing in complete vegetarians. Vegetarian diets decrease TMAO.9

  5. Leafy greens and beets promote increased nitric oxide levels which lower blood pressure and improve circulation. One shot of beet juice improves time to exhaustion from 9 min 43 seconds to 10:57 and 11 min 15 seconds in one study.10

  6. Added phosphates are avoided with a plant-based diet. Red meat and colas and other processed foods have phosphates added to enhance or preserve color. In addition, phosphates prevent seepage of fluid from the meat. We have all seen meat that has been there for a few days that has weird juice in the package. Phosphate helps prevent this. Phosphates are vascular toxins and cause vascular calcification.11 The recommended daily maximum intake is 700 mg. Daily intake can be double or triple that when processed foods are eaten. High phosphate intake is more prevalent in underserved, poorly educated and impoverished populations. Phosphate toxicity is quickly becoming a global health concern. Without measures in place to reduce dietary phosphate intake, the conditions associated with phosphate toxicity will likely increase. Taking extra magnesium, vitamin K, and vitamin D can help mitigate the effects of phosphates on calcification. Niacin and magnesium can even reduce the absorption of phosphate.12

  7. Salt intake typically goes down because processed meats, cheese, deli meats and even raw chicken are high in salt. Chicken is typically injected with salt water to increase his weight. Cheese is also remarkably high in salt. In addition to increasing blood pressure salt can also impair artery function cause damage to the artery wall. Salt can hurt our arteries independent of its impact on blood pressure.13 We know this because researchers discovered that after high sodium meal there is significantly less blood flow to the extremities. Interestingly, injection of vitamin C reversed the blood flow impairment. The reason for this is that vitamin C as an antioxidant and salt suppresses the activity of the key antioxidant enzyme in the body called superoxide dismutase. The vitamin C restores the activity of the superoxide dismutase.

    • If one were to compare the following foods which one would you guess is the most sodium. A serving of beef, a serving of baked all-natural chicken, a large McDonald’s French fries or serving of salted pretzels? The answer is chicken. Consumer Reports found that most supermarket rotisserie chicken contained 840 mg of sodium per serving about half the daily requirement.
  8. Fiber intake goes way up as a result of eating more plant foods. Fiber is critically important newer research points to numerous benefits. Fiber improves the distribution of friendly microbes in your GI tract known as the microbiota. Both soluble and insoluble fiber decrease the risk of colon cancer and diverticulitis. Eating more fiber lowers blood pressure, lowers cholesterol, reduces risk of colon cancer, improves bowel function and prevents weight gain.

  9. Beneficial phytonutrient intake goes way up.

    • Beta-carotene is important for bone health, skin health, vision and the immune system. Food sources are apricots, squash, carrots, sweet potato, collard greens, spinach, kale, and broccoli.
    • Lycopene is associated with less cardiovascular disease and reduction of prostate cancer risk. Good sources are red peppers, pink grapefruit, tomatoes, and watermelon. The heating process helps the absorption of lycopene. Tomato paste would be an exceedingly high source.
    • Lutein helps with eye health, heart health and the prevention of cancer. Good sources are broccoli, spinach, kale, collard greens, brussels sprouts, and artichoke. It is particularly important for the macula of the eye.
    • Resveratrol is particularly important for prevention of cancer, lung function and lowering inflammation. Good sources are red wine, peanuts and grapes.
    • Anthocyanidins are especially important for heart and blood vessel health. Good sources are strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, plums, cranberries, raspberries, red onions, red potatoes and radishes.
    • Isoflavones help with the prevention of breast cancer, improve bone health, lower joint inflammation and help lower cholesterol. The main source is soybeans.
    • Lignans have a weak estrogen-like effect. Lignans bind to estrogen receptors and prevent stronger estrogens from entering the cell. An exceptionally good source is ground flaxseeds. Flaxseeds also contain type of fiber that lowers cholesterol, helps with blood pressure and improve bowel health. The oil and flaxseed known as alpha linolenic acid is an essential fatty acid.
    • Potassium intake goes way up on plant-based diet. The best source of potassium is fruits and vegetables, nuts and seeds. Throughout most of human history we ate much more potassium and less sodium. Potassium helps lower blood pressure whereas sodium raises it. Therefore, simply eating more fruits and vegetables can lower blood pressure. The recommended daily amount is 4700 mg and some authors have suggested only 2 percent of Americans achieve that. As potassium intake increases risk of stroke decreases. Bananas are not the best source. Better sources are leafy greens, potatoes, sweet potatoes and beans. Pomegranate juice also has an amazingly high level. Rankings of foods high in potassium are easy to Google.
    • Antioxidants are abundant in plant foods. Antioxidants help protect your DNA, arteries, and protect the body from environmental toxins. Plant foods are richest source. The more darkly pigmented something is the more antioxidant phytonutrients a contains. Rankings of foods by antioxidant levels are easy to find online. One source of antioxidants that is underappreciated are those found in herbs and spices. It is better to get your antioxidants from food rather than supplements.
    • Herbs and spices: Cook with turmeric, curcumin, curry, cilantro, cayenne pepper, ginger, peppermint, oregano, marjoram, cloves, and cinnamon. One study showed that the main source of antioxidants and the American diet was cinnamon in the next was beer! Yes, hops has antioxidants.
    • Garlic contains sulfides including Allicin. Garlic is an antioxidant and can help lower cholesterol.
    • Brazil nuts have been shown to lower cholesterol and contain selenium.
    • Mushrooms can increase IgA levels in the saliva strengthening the immune system and decreasing inflammation. A study published in the journal Experimental Biology and Medicine showed that most mushrooms, even the white ones at the supermarket, had significant suppressive effects on breast cancer growth. One phytonutrient found in shiitake mushrooms called lentinan has been shown to improve immune function which can slow the growth of tumors. This information comes from Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. Mushrooms contain beta glucan which is also been found to improve immune function. The fiber in mushrooms, namely chitin and beta glucan, were shown to lower cholesterol in the study done by the International Journal of Medicinal Mushrooms. Mushrooms also contain two antioxidants called ergothioneine and glutathione which both help lower inflammation. Cooking mushrooms helps with digestion and absorption. Mushrooms are good source of protein.

Let’s lose fat!

It’s easier to lose weight with a meat free diet. According to the EPIC PANACEA14 study total meat consumption was positively associated with weight gain in men and women, in normal-weight and overweight subjects. With calorie intake being equal, an increase in meat intake of 250 g/d (eg, one steak at approximately 450 kcal) would lead to a 2-kg higher weight gain after 5 y. This was true for for red meat, poultry, and processed meat. The conclusion of the study was that a decrease in meat consumption may improve weight management.

In summary, the scientific literature is clear regarding the health benefits of a whole foods plant-based diet. I will spare you now but I could list pages of studies backing up plant-based diet as the way to go for heart health. An excellent resource for data not dogma nutritionfacts.org. The negative consequences of processed food and animal food consumption is also clear. At least in the United States going with the flow and not paying attention will get you in trouble. Going with the flow equals too much sodium, not enough fiber, too much saturated fat, carcinogens and too many calories. I do not think a one size fits all approach to human diet is the answer either. I will typically work individually with patients to find balance. When I say “avoid” it means “make a strong attempt to avoid”.

Even if your diet is far from optimal adding more fruits, berries, vegetables, raw nuts, leafy greens will help balance any negatives in the diet. As an example, if you are going more Paleo/Cave man just buy organic and eat a lot of vegetables. If you are doing a ketogenic diet eat only raw organic fats, organic meats and eggs and include at least 5-6 servings of low starch low sugar plant foods and take ground flaxseed to add fiber.

Anyone interested only in weight loss only is being shortsighted. Just like with investing you want to think long-term not short term. Weight loss is too general a term anyway. I like my patients to strive for a sustainable way of eating without ups and downs and dramatic changes that includes foods and recipes they like. Weight loss that includes muscle loss is a concerning medical condition and will lower metabolic rate.

Plant based people should not fall into the trap of processed foods. It takes extra work to follow this diet and more time in the kitchen. There are plenty of companies that will deliver preprepared meals or ingredients for making meals to make it easier. Everyone should avoid junk food and ultra-processed foods. There is nothing wrong with treating yourself occasionally. This helps with cravings and is like a reward for having such a clean diet. Overall health is what’s important. Eating whole foods plant-based diet we will keep you out of the emergency room the hospital and reduce your risk of dying from the 3 main causes of death which include heart disease stroke and cancer.

This article was also published in Naturopathic Doctor News & Review as Think Beets, Not Meat! Vegetarian Diets and Cardiovascular Health.